rank songs on 3

**topik killer** · 01.29.01, 10:47 AM

i had a little time on my hands (alot actually), so i ranked the songs off 3 best to worst and included the instrumentals:

1) WITHOUT YOU
2) FIRE IN THE HOLE
3) BALLOT OR THE BULLET
4) FROM AFAR
5) JOSEPHINA
6) ONCE
7) YEAR TO THE DAY
8) ONE I WANT
9) DIRTY WATER DOG
10) NEWORLD
11) PRIMARY
12) HOW MANY SAY I

**Glenn** · 01.29.01, 11:21 AM

Hmm, how long before someone jumps all over this thread title?

1. Year to the Day
2. Without You
3. Fire in the Hole
4. From Afar
5. One I Want
6. Once
7. Dirty Water Dog
8. Josephina
9. Ballot or the Bullet
10. Neworld
11. Primary
12. How Many Say I

Too bad TWILY wasn't on there; for me, it would have been top 5 for sure on the list.

------------------
The Michael Jordan of Van Halen websites!!!
www.vhlinks.com

**RAFTER** · 01.29.01, 03:40 PM

1. New World
2. Year To The Day
3. Primary
4. Without You
5. From Afar
6. Fire In The Hole
7. Ballot Or The Bullet
8. Josephina
9. One I Want
10.Dirty Water Dog
11.How Many Say I / Once

------------------
Hot damn burn an amsterdamn! "The almighy Red Rocker

**Dan Halen** · 01.29.01, 04:26 PM

1. Fire In The Hole
2. Without You
3. One I Want
4. Year To The Day
5. Dirty Water Dog
6. Once
7. From Afar
8. Ballot Or The Bullet
9. Neworld
10. Josephina
11. Primary
12. How Many Say I

------------------
"If Gary's in, he's in for life--that's it. And if anything ever does happen, then I'll score movies or whatever, but that would be the end of Van Halen. I'll take up tuba." --EVH, Entertainment Weekly, 1996

Dan Halen

**Cabo Kid** · 01.30.01, 04:53 AM

1. From Afar
2. Without You
3. Fire In The Hole
4. Year To The Day
5. One I Want
6. Ballot Or The Bullet
7. Dirty Water Dog
8. Josephina
9. Neworld
10. Primary
11. How Many Say I?

*TWILY would have been top 3 had it been included on the actual cd.

------------------
"Whenever we come to Milwaukee, we try and have a special surprise for you here and tonite we got a whole sh*tload of 'em for you and right now, we want to whip the first one at you here! Y'know, usually Ed doesn't sing this part of the song and when he does tonight for the first time, you'll find out why!"

-David Lee Roth, Milwaukee 1980

**Stuff No More** · 01.30.01, 08:16 AM

I'll take a stab at this.

Dirty Water Dog
Without You
From Afar
Once
Fire in the Hole
Year to the Day
One I Want
Ballot or the Bullet
Neworld
How Many Say I
Primary

------------------
Fall in line, say the word...
VHLinks Forum Moderator (Opinions)
Up Front Fanatics!

**YankeeRose** · 01.30.01, 08:44 AM

Cool top two songs Stuff.

Here's my picks in order.....

Dirty Water Dog
Without You
One I Want
Josephina
Year to the Day
Fire in the Hole
Ballot or the Bullet
Neworld
Primary
From Afar
Once
How Many Say I

------------------
Right Now you're reading my post!
She's a vision from coast to coast...
Kicking back ain't kicking you...
Don't disturb my paradise,
i've asked you once, I asked you nice...
Up Front Fanatics!

**Georgie** · 01.30.01, 10:53 AM

1)Without You
2)Fire in the Hole
3)One I Want
4)Dirty Water Dog
5)Ballot or the Bullet
6)From Afar
7)New World
8)Josephina
9)Primary
10)Once
11)How Many Say I
12)Year to the Day

**Cabo5150** · 01.30.01, 11:00 AM

1. Dirty Water Dog
2. One I Want
3. Without You
4. Fire in the Hole
5. Ballot or the Bullet
6. From Afar
7. Year to the Day
8. Primary
9. Once
10. Neworld
11. Josephina
12. How Many Say I

In all actuallity, this is not that bad of an album. It's not a great VH album. But if Gary would of stayed with Extreme and they put this album out, I might of liked a lot better.

------------------
Red Rocker Face Down in Cabo!!!

**Garywascooltoo** · 01.30.01, 12:59 PM

1. Year to the Day
2. Without You
3. Neworld
(3. Tie with honorary song That's Why I Love You)
4. From Afar
5. Once
6. Josephina
7. Fire In the Hole
8. Dirty Water Dog
9. One I Want
10.Ballot or the Bullet
11.Primary
12.How Many Say I

------------------
"Forked tongue in double-speak"

"Your iron lung's a bag of wind"

**Dan Halen** · 01.30.01, 05:05 PM

<BLOCKQUOTE>quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Georgie:

11)How Many Say I
12)Year to the Day<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

Year To The Day worse than How Many Say I??? Wow, please explain.

------------------
"If Gary's in, he's in for life--that's it. And if anything ever does happen, then I'll score movies or whatever, but that would be the end of Van Halen. I'll take up tuba." --EVH, Entertainment Weekly, 1996

Dan Halen

**RAFTER** · 01.30.01, 05:23 PM

Whats up with everybody layin the smackdown on primary and neworld? Those are the best!!

------------------
Hot damn burn an amsterdamn! "The almighy Red Rocker

**Crossing Over** · 01.30.01, 09:06 PM

1.Without you
2.Fire in the hole
3.Dirty water dog
4.Once
5.How many say I
6.One I want
7.From Afar
8.Neworld
9.Joshepina
10.Ballot or the bullet
11.Year to the day
12.Primary

------------------
What is understood need not be discussed.

Everybody is lookin´ for somethin´; somethin´ to fill in the holes...? is Van Halen right???

Strung Out Moderator

My website:

http://www.vhvault.com/crossingover

**6String** · 01.30.01, 11:16 PM

1.From Afar
2.Fire in the Hole
3.Without You
4.One I Want
5.Josephina
6.Neworld
7.Ballot or The Bullet
8.Dirty Water Dog
9.Primary
10.Year to The Day
11.Once
12.How Many Say I

**Rat Salad** · 01.30.01, 11:27 PM

Ya guys....tell us why ya ranked Year to the Day so low...just curious....anyways...

1. Year to the Day
2. From Afar
3. One I Want
4. Ballot or the Bullet
5. Neworld
6. Without You
7. Primary
8. Josephina
9. Fire in the Hole kick ass outro!
10. Once kick ass call and response between Ed and Gary towards the end.
11. Dirty Water Dog
12. How Many Say I would have been alot better if it remained an instrumental

------------------

Here's to your thin red line....MMMMMM I'm stepping over!