Check out this chic

[evhintexas]

[PrideofPasadena]

Wow! That was pretty good.

[danielleesale]

Did her own thing in parts but still landed on her feet.

[Brett]

That’s all right. Her Unchained cover is a trainwreck though.

[edwardv]

Nice try but hard no.

Sent from my LML212VL using Tapatalk

[Brett]

And her tone is awful.

[MF5150]

There is nothing quite like grown men cutting down another guitar player, and a young girl no less, who's giving these old school VH tunes a go.

[Get The Show On The Road]

She looks like Val.

[noise next door]

I wonder if she walked into Guitar Center and bought that guitar herself or her Parents bought it for her.

Would be very cool to have a daughter that loved to play VH

[MF5150]

She looks like Val.

So she basically looks like a young Eddie

[Dave's Dreidel]

That’s all right. Her Unchained cover is a trainwreck though.

Was waiting for a real musician to say it and not a hack like me, but yeah, I didn't think that was very good.

[Dave's Dreidel]

There is nothing quite like grown men cutting down another guitar player, and a young girl no less, who's giving these old school VH tunes a go.

Saying she doesn't play the song well isn't cutting her, it's simply a fact. Would you rather we lie and tell her how great she was?

[Wruff_ajax]

Big tip of the hat to her gunning for this stuff. That was cool. She'll get there. Certainly well on her way.

[MF5150]

Saying she doesn't play the song well isn't cutting her, it's simply a fact. Would you rather we lie and tell her how great she was?

I guess I'm just not as inclined as you in playing the role of Simon Cowell...

She's a young girl playing VH on YouTube, man. Would you walk up to her in a guitar store and tell her "how shit her tone is" if she was playing? I didn't think so. Eddie probably wouldn't respond like that, either.

As a guitar player, it's just petty, IMO. I'd just assume not say anything because if some teenager was a member here and wanted to post themselves playing a VH track, and they read some of the negative/petty shit exhibited here, they might be dissuaded from doing so or even playing guitar at all. And that's pretty sad.

But if you're cool with the rude critiquing a young girl who's playing some tunes of your favourite band, whatever floats your boat man.

We were all inexperienced at some point in our instrument playing lives. I find it funny when people forget that.

[Get The Show On The Road]

Saying she doesn't play the song well isn't cutting her, it's simply a fact. Would you rather we lie and tell her how great she was?

It's okay to critique the fact that the playing needs some work. For someone who i presume hasn't been playing for long that's to be expected.

It's not horrible but there are parts that aren't very fluid either.

I'm guessing that will improve in time.