Peace Sells...But Who's Buying or Master of Puppets?

**Wild Ranger** · 11.30.19, 02:27 PM

Which thrash metal classic from 1986 do you prefer?

**Dave's Dreidel** · 11.30.19, 08:12 PM

I like Peace Sells, but MOP is nails. Not even close.

**DJ Work'in Hard** · 11.30.19, 08:17 PM

I think Puppets will win easily

**japeape** · 11.30.19, 08:44 PM

I absolutely love & adore both albums, bought them & was blown away.

Peace Sells, is easily my fave Megadeth album, it's just that freaking good.

But, i gotta go back to those early years, and remember how MOP effected
me, upon first listen.

That album (MOP) was a game changer.

I recognized it's brilliance straight away.

I voted MOP.

**edwardv** · 12.01.19, 06:01 AM

I vote neither. But I like Mustaine.

**bklynboy68** · 12.01.19, 06:17 AM

MOP all the way.

**RRvh1** · 12.01.19, 08:33 AM

Originally Posted by edwardv

I vote neither. But I like Mustaine.

I vote neither, but later adored the Black album, as well as the song Hangar 18 by Megadeth (in their fourteenth incarnation?).

**Naked Wake** · 12.01.19, 01:28 PM

I love Megadeth more than I do Metallica, and PSB?B is an awesome album, but MOP by 10,000 yards.

Again, as much as I love Megadeth, I think Dave was always a step or two behind. Dave should feel honored that Megadeth is even considered one of the Big Four of thrash/speed metal.

**Big Guitars** · 12.01.19, 07:09 PM

Definitely Master of Puppets for me.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

**Little Dreamer** · 12.01.19, 09:49 PM

Master is a monumental record. I think every riff, every solo is right on the money. There's no filler track. It's not even a thrash record any more, it's just a landmark rock record.

**Ian Sane** · 12.02.19, 03:45 AM

It's gotta be Master Of Puppets for me. I reckon that's Metallica's best album.
As good as Peace Sells... But Who's Buying? is, I feel Megadeth's strongest is Rust In Peace.

**ziggysmalls** · 12.02.19, 04:22 AM

Never could get over Mustaine's voice. That said, MOP is the perfect thrash/metal album. Metallica at their peak.

**Simon Ribeiro** · 12.02.19, 04:37 AM

Originally Posted by Wild Ranger

Which thrash metal classic from 1986 do you prefer?

That's a nice poll, man! Kudos!!

It has to be Dave and Megadeth's 2nd effort. By far! Miles ahead of Metallica's 3rd record. And I even enjoy that one, but not as much as I love Ride the Lightning.

While Metallica kind of started to use the same formula they got from RTL, Peace Sells is like an all brand new stuff from Megadeth. Killing is my business ... is still one of my favourite records and then the band released something that was even better! Excellent song writing. Lots of great guitar shredding. Cool lyrics. And it has both Chris Poland and Gar Samuelson. IMHO, these 02 1st records still have Megadeth's best line up. I even include The System Has Failed ranked ahead of Rust in Peace, Countdown, Youthnasia or The World Needs a Hero.

**Darrin Stephens** · 12.02.19, 04:57 AM

I prefer megadeth but Metallica is overall the better band

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

**Simon Ribeiro** · 12.02.19, 05:04 AM

Originally Posted by ziggysmalls

Never could get over Mustaine's voice. That said, MOP is the perfect thrash/metal album. Metallica at their peak.

Man ... It has to be me, but I love Mustaine's voice since day 01.

Probably you never listened to, but I think Dave did a great job singing his parts damn well on Risk (their 8th album released in 1999).