5150 vs VH3

**Spanish Doctor** · 03.31.00, 11:24 AM

Which is in your humble opinion people, the best album, 5150 or VH3 ?

**VanEdge** · 03.31.00, 11:28 AM

this thread is gonna get moved to Albums or Opinions.

anyway, 5150 wins, hands down. it was a band effort, end of story.

**Glenn** · 03.31.00, 11:29 AM

I gotta go with 5150 here, and I think most people will agree. Better songs, better sound. 5150 is a great album, which was badly needed after Dave leaving.

**Raldo** · 03.31.00, 11:30 AM

I'm trying not to laugh when I answer this question. 5150 all the way. Album really rocks, he can hear Mike's vocals, Ed isn't singing and the production is so much better.

**Spanish Doctor** · 03.31.00, 11:32 AM

as for me, well, personally, IMHO i think that vh3 well hum... shall i say... huh...

sucked.

**redfire** · 03.31.00, 12:23 PM

Lets see now, maybe VH's best album versus maybe VH's worst album.

I am going to go out on a limb

and dare I say.... 5150.

------------------
Eat Us And Smile!

The self-proclaimed Heart Break Kid of VHLinks!

Your frienldy, neighborhood Ice Cream Man.

**OLO** · 03.31.00, 12:41 PM

No comparison - 5150 rocks I can listen to the entire album and frequently do.

VHIII - Well I pretty much bought it the day it came out and had not even heard a song from it. I paid like $30 bucks for it, it was the one that came with all the picks and the hard case. Driving home from Tower I remember thinking what the hell is this??? There are really only a couple of songs I like off the album. It doesnt make it into the CD player that often.

------------------
((Just My Two Cents))
and thats about what its worth

**Fkal** · 03.31.00, 12:59 PM

Overall, as compared to previous VH albums, i was disappointed with VH3...although, there were some interesting ideas on it, definitely a departure for the band in some ways (ex. Once, and Ed singing lead)...5150 just rocks, has some great lasting tunes on it...i still remember blasting 'Summer Nights' when cruising down the Jersey shore