"Without You" Is a great song!

[VHrox12]

Ok, an olive branch, there is one song on VHIII that I don't despise. I actually really like it.

Haha. Yeah the one instrumental song on the album before "Ballot Or The Bullet" other than "Neworld". I get why you like it, lol.

[PrideofPasadena]

I'm 44 and it's just outside of my Top 10

Actually, what I said was wrong. It's not hard to believe kids at the time liked it cuz it's part of their youth. Which, is what I was getting at. You were young at the time. It resonated more with you. Us, 30, 40 year old's, at the time....not so much.

[DFVH5150]

Actually, what I said was wrong. It's not hard to believe kids at the time liked it cuz it's part of their youth. Which, is what I was getting at. You were young at the time. It resonated more with you. Us, 30, 40 year old's, at the time....not so much.

It's cool. I guess I was in my early 20s at the time which is close enough to being a teen.

[I Heard]

If we take the exact same songs and just swap out the singer with various people, does the album improve? Here is my list.

Without You- Sammy Hagar
One I want - Brian Johnson or Axl Rose
From Afar- Ozzy Osbourne
Dirty Water Dog- David Lee Roth
Once- Phil Collins
Fire In The Hole- Sass Jordan
Josephina- Steven Tyler
Year to the Day- Robert Plant
Ballot Or The Bullet- David Lee Roth
How Many Say I- Roger Waters

[I Coulda Hada VH]

If we take the exact same songs and just swap out the singer with various people, does the album improve? Here is my list.

Without You- Sammy Hagar
One I want - Brian Johnson or Axl Rose
From Afar- Ozzy Osbourne
Dirty Water Dog- David Lee Roth
Once- Phil Collins
Fire In The Hole- Sass Jordan
Josephina- Steven Tyler
Year to the Day- Robert Plant
Ballot Or The Bullet- David Lee Roth
How Many Say I- Roger Waters

The only things wrong with the songs on Van Halen III are the music, lyrics and vocals. Other than that, it's pure gold.

[DFVH5150]

The only things wrong with the songs on Van Halen III are the music, lyrics and vocals. Other than that, it's pure gold.

I'd like to you see your rankings from disliked the most to dislike the least on that album, Coulda. Number One would be "favorite" and go down from there.

And for fun, please throw in "It's the Right Time."

[I Coulda Hada VH]

I'd like to you see your rankings from disliked the most to dislike the least on that album, Coulda. Number One would be "favorite" and go down from there.

And for fun, please throw in "It's the Right Time."

This sounds like a version of Sophie's Choice in which I have a dozen children, all of whom I hate.

[DFVH5150]

This sounds like a version of Sophie's Choice in which I have a dozen children, all of whom I hate.

Okay, your least disliked song then.

[Van Squalen]

The only things wrong with the songs on Van Halen III are the music, lyrics and vocals. Other than that, it's pure gold.

Hey. At least they threw in a pink guitar pick in the special edition CD tin.

Your least disliked song is FITH. The rest of the album is toilet wash.

[I Coulda Hada VH]

Hey. At least they threw in a pink guitar pick in the special edition CD tin.

Your least disliked song is FITH. The rest of the album is toilet wash.

Whaddup, VS?

[Van Squalen]

Whaddup, VS?

Same old end of the world horseshit. You?

[I Coulda Hada VH]

Same old end of the world horseshit. You?

Just looking forward to the end of this pandemic.

[Van Squalen]

Just looking forward to the end of this pandemic.

Ya think?

[I Coulda Hada VH]

Ya think?

Occasionally.

[Van Squalen]

Occasionally.

I found a pic of us online at the GNR show lounging in those couches. Some photog must’ve taken it outside walking around the forum mezzanine. I wish I could remember where I saw it.