That´s Why I Love You Vs. Joshepina

**Glenn** · 09.14.00, 04:52 PM

Between the two, I prefer TWILY, but I do think that Josephina is a beautiful song. It's especially poignant knowing that it was written about the band members' mothers.

**YankeeRose** · 09.14.00, 06:23 PM

I like Josphina better because I think Gary's singing is very good on it. I don't like the way Gary sings on TWILY, The harmonies really suck right before the solo too! I can't make out what they're singing. Thank Mike Post for that.

------------------
Right Now you're reading my post!
Here's a shot heard round the world...
Sometimes I just want to do nothing...

**Dan Halen** · 09.14.00, 10:21 PM

I like Josephina, but would have rather had TWILY on VH3.

------------------
Dan Halen
http://www.geocities.com/dan_halen27/main.html

**Stuff No More** · 09.15.00, 11:23 AM

While I prefer TWILY a lot more, I totally understand why Eddie would want to replace it with a song about his mother having cancer. It makes it kind of hard to knock that song on anything...

------------------
RIGHT NOW I'm livin' on the corner of Mean St. and Old Amsterdam Blvd.
--------
"Take your vitamin "T" with salt 'n lemon slice ..."
UP FRONT FANATIC!

**Wolfie3** · 09.15.00, 06:13 PM

TWILY by a mile. Matter of fact, I think I like TWILY better than any song on VH3. I really wish they would have put it on the album.

------------------
E.B.A.S.

RUNNIN' WITH THE DEVIL - HOUSE OF PAIN: The greatest ride in Rock & Roll history ...
GOOD ENOUGH - HOW MANY SAY I: Not a bad trip either ...

"Someone asked me the other day what I thought I had learned about making music after all these years, and I said, 'Nothing'." -EVH

**Spanish Doctor** · 09.15.00, 07:24 PM

both songs suck, Gary's "vocals" ruin everything for me, can't decide.

------------------
Eat Us And Smile!!!

**seenbad** · 09.15.00, 08:22 PM

Going to go with Josephina here. It was just fantastic live. One of the highlights of the show here in Portland IMO.

------------------
sheepa latta peepah dabba looka foh a moopy

Ohhh my god , my hell inside me ... hey guys ... we need that the womens come back !
YUUNNK!! (eddie italian)

**Down In Flames** · 09.18.00, 02:42 AM

TWILY is a great song.

It should have replaced Josephina. I can't stand this song, man. Nothing appealing about it.

------------------
"Fuck you. I give you my ass." - Rick S' dog, as interpreted by track 5

Official Bartender Of VHLinks

**homeunit** · 09.18.00, 02:57 AM

Really? I thought Joshepina was one of the stronger tunes off of VH3! Especially right after the solo! Although TWILY should have made it in lou of How Many Say I, that should have been a private gift from Ed to Val

IMHO

------------------
Guitar Room player files http://www.freedrive.com/
UN: vhlinks
PW: vhlinks

Baluchitherium
G4
"back to you, underpants" -Big Red Allan

**Down In Flames** · 09.18.00, 11:53 AM

Well, Josephina was too bizarre for my ears. I didn't like the lyrics, Ed's tone on it, the bass... Well, the bass was a problem on the whole damn album, so I won't single out just this song. LOL

So homeunit, how about a compromise?

We put TWILY on VH 3. For me we take off Josephina, and for you - we take off How Many Say I? Not only do we both get rid of a song we don't like, but we add a song we DO like - AND we cut that monstrously-sized album down a few minutes in the process.

(If only VH's world could be so easy.

)

------------------
"Fuck you. I give you my ass." - Rick S' dog, as interpreted by track 5

Official Bartender Of VHLinks

[This message has been edited by Down In Flames (edited September 18, 2000 at 10:54 AM).]

**homeunit** · 09.18.00, 01:16 PM

I think if we start cutting out tracks we're going to end up with nothing real quick

------------------
Guitar Room player files http://www.freedrive.com/
UN: vhlinks
PW: vhlinks

Baluchitherium
G4
"back to you, underpants" -Big Red Allan